Does PLA Creep? 18 Months of Library Loans Say Not Much

Blog

Does PLA Creep? 18 Months of Library Loans Say Not Much

Previous

Does PLA Creep? 18 Months of Library Loans Say Not Much

Terry and a curious dog with Candy Floss, a pink and mint 3D printed telescope, in the workshop

Terry with Candy Floss after 18 months on loan. The dog supervised.

Ask around about printing anything that has to carry weight in PLA, and someone will say "creep." It's a fair worry. PLA softens at a fairly low temperature, and a part under steady load can slowly sag, stretch or flatten over time. Silk PLA has an even softer reputation, since the additives that make it shiny trade away a little strength.

So we put it to a real-world test. Candy Floss is a Skyward 150 Compact telescope whose pink and mint parts are all Silk PLA from our own shelf. (We don't sell Silk PLA any more, but we keep a few spools around for builds like this.) For the last 18 months it has been a loaner in the Blue Door Astronomy Library, going home with families on four-week loans: in and out of cars, set up on lawns and stored wherever borrowers had room.

Then and Now

We didn't measure the parts when they were new, so there are no before-and-after numbers. What we do have is the build video, which shows the same parts fresh off the printer. That makes a decent "before."

Freshly printed pink and mint Silk PLA parts for Candy Floss on the workbench during the build

Then: Candy Floss's parts on the bench during the build, including a brand-new mint foot on the left.

Candy Floss fully assembled on its mount at the end of the build video

Then: assembled for the first time at the end of the build.

Where Creep Would Show First

The parts under the most constant load are the feet. The whole scope rests on them every minute it's set up, and they're Silk PLA domes capping the tripod legs.

Three brand-new mint Silk PLA dome feet on the workbench during the build

Then: brand-new feet on the bench during the build.

The same mint dome feet after 18 months, scuffed but still round

Now: after 18 months of loans. Scuffed and grubby, but still round.

Side view of a mint Silk PLA dome foot showing a smooth, round profile

Side on, the curve is still clean all the way down to the leg.

The worn patches are exactly that: wear from being set down on concrete, gravel and decks. Worn is not the same as squashed. If the feet had crept, the tops would be flattened and the edges would be spreading out over the leg. They aren't.

Up top, the tube rings and the star wheel still sit square, and the tube doesn't droop. That's the real test. Collimation is routine on any Newtonian, but a ring or foot that has slumped out of shape can't be adjusted back.

Close-up of Candy Floss's pink tube rings and mint star wheel after 18 months, still square and aligned

Now: rings and star wheel after 18 months, still square.

So, Should You Print Load-Bearing Parts in PLA?

For something like this, kept at room temperature and used outdoors at night, PLA did the job. Where it can still let you down is heat. PLA starts to soften at around 55 to 60 °C, and a car in a July parking lot can get hotter than that. That's how PLA parts end up warped for good, and it's where ABS, ASA or PETG earn their keep. Our filament guide goes through the trade-offs.

Want the telescope side of the story? Ten Telescopes has a builder's take: Candy Floss: 18 Months on Loan and Still Holding Its Shape.

Candy Floss is still in service, by the way. You can borrow it from the Blue Door Astronomy Library.