Caught in the Web: How a Spiderweb Fixed Our Warping Problem

Blog

Caught in the Web: How a Spiderweb Fixed Our Warping Problem

Previous

Caught in the Web: How a Spiderweb Fixed Our Warping Problem

Next

Of all the parts in our Skyward telescopes, the rocker box base looks like the easiest. It's a flat slab with a few holes in it. What's the big deal, right?

CAD model of the original Skyward rocker box, with the flat black rocker box base slab along the bottom
Our original rocker box in CAD. The base is the black slab along the bottom. Simple, right?

Turns out it's one of the hardest parts we print. Here's how it cost me a stack of glass beds, and how a spiderweb finally fixed it.

Why a Flat Slab Is So Hard

We print the bases in ABS. It's tough and handles heat well, but it shrinks as it cools. Every new layer pulls on the layers below it. On a small part you'd never notice. On a slab more than 250 mm across, all that pulling adds up, and the corners want to curl up off the bed. That's warping.

Stick It Down Harder?

My first answer was adhesion. I tried glue stick. I tried hairspray. I tried ABS slurry. Eventually I got the parts stuck down really, really well.

That's when the glass started cracking.

The warping force didn't go away just because the part couldn't lift. It went into the bed instead. I cracked at least eight glass beds that way. Sometimes the glass even came off still stuck to the part.

A glass print bed shattered by curved cracks, with the outline of a large ribbed ABS part still on its surface
One of at least eight glass beds that didn't make it. The ghost of the part is still on it.
A glass print bed on an early printer with one crack running its full width
One crack, right across the bed.
The corner of a cream ABS telescope part with a piece of broken glass still bonded to it
When the adhesion wins, the glass comes along for the ride.

To be fair to the base, it wasn't the only culprit. Any big, flat ABS telescope part could do this. The base was just the flattest and the most stubborn.

Turn Up the Heat

A warm chamber helps ABS a lot, because the part cools more slowly and more evenly. So I built a dog house: a box of foil-faced foam board with a little window, sitting right over the printer.

A homemade printer enclosure built from foil-faced foam insulation board, with a square viewing window
The dog house. Not pretty, but warm.
A second glass bed with two long curved cracks, inside a foil-lined enclosure
Warmer, and still cracking.

It helped. It didn't solve it. Over the years I tried just about everything, and even the newest printers didn't make the problem go away. The fix wasn't going to come from the printer. It had to come from the part.

Designing the Infill Ourselves

Most people let the slicer pick the infill. For the bases, I started drawing the infill right into the CAD model, so I could control exactly where the plastic goes.

The first try, on the original Skyward 150, was a grid of cone-shaped cups. The second, on the Skyward 150 Compact, was a grid of round cells.

Cross-section of the original Skyward 150 rocker box base showing a grid of round cone-shaped cups
Try 1: cone-shaped cups.
Cross-section of the Skyward 150 Compact rocker box base showing a square grid of round cells
Try 2: round cells.

Closer, but not the fix.

Caught in the Web

The breakthrough came with the Skyward 200. I finally figured out what was really going on: long, connected runs of infill were acting like strings, all pulling on each other as they cooled. The longer the run, the harder the pull.

So I drew a spiderweb. Rings circle out from the centre pivot, joined by short spokes that are staggered from ring to ring, like bricks. No wall runs straight for long. And because the walls are curved, they can give a little as the plastic shrinks, instead of dragging the whole slab up at the corners.

Cross-section of the Skyward 200 rocker box base showing a spiderweb of concentric rings and short staggered spokes
Try 3: the spiderweb. Short walls, lots of curves, nowhere for the stress to build up.

And here's what that looks like in real life.

The concentric rings and short spokes of a spiderweb base being printed
Every wall is short or curved. Nothing runs straight across the slab.
Close-up of the spiderweb infill cells inside a printed rocker box base
Up close, it looks a lot like brickwork.

Where It Stands Now

The spiderweb bases just print now. Our Bambu H2 printers run them routinely, and the Vorons had no trouble with them either. We've made dozens of them in ABS, and no more glass beds have been harmed.

A spiderweb base printing, sped up. Not the best camera angle, but keep an eye on the front corner. It never lifts.

And once it's off the bed? Flat as a pancake.

A finished spiderweb base. Sight down the edge: no curl at the corners.

If You're Fighting Warping Too

  • More adhesion isn't always the answer. If the part can't lift, the stress goes somewhere else, like your bed.
  • Heat helps, but it isn't a cure. A warm chamber slows things down. It doesn't take the stress away.
  • Look at the shape of the infill. Long, straight, connected lines pull hard. Short, curved walls can flex.

Eight glass beds. Three infill designs. One spiderweb.

Got a big, flat part that won't stay flat? Let's talk about your project.